Well, this is interesting. From the top: Dylon®, Tulip® and Procion MX



I’ll be back with more on this later.
I’m back.
Comments on the colors – The Tulip® kit and the Procion colors I used are similar: Turquoise, Lemon and Fuchsia. The Dylon® colors I purchased were different in the Blue (Cobalt) and Yellow (Golden). It made a difference in the result, but not the test.
I was quite surprised that the Tulip® lost so much of the blue. It really faded away. Also, the red didn’t dissolve very well and left dye marks.
After seeing what happened with the Tulip®, I strained the Dylon® and the blue still wasn’t completely dissolved. Go figure.
The Tulip® is marketed as a direct dye and fails in this application. It is not very vibrant and the blue virtually disappears. It may do better on a t-shirt due to the density of the fiber, but I wouldn’t waste my money.
The Dylon® is marketed as a vat dye, but does, o.k. in direct dye application. I would try the Dylon® with less water, perhaps halving it to 2 cups to enhance the vibrancy of the colors. I really like the how these particular colors reacted with the fabric – the dye ‘traveled’ well and enhanced the folding/swirling of the fabric.
What I also found interesting was how these dyes performed on silk – especially the raw silk and silk/rayon velvet. You can actually see the Tulip® blue!
So the bottom line – If you want to try dyeing to see if you like it, I would get the Dylon®. You get more dye for your money and you can adjust the intensity by adding less water. Plus, it is simple and easy to use.
These pictures show the results from a different technique: pouring the dye over the fabric, squishing it, squeezing it out, scrunching up the fabric, putting it in a container and pouring the remaining solution over the fabric in the container. The top row is the Dylon®, the middle row Tulip® and the bottom row the Procion. From the right, the fabrics are: silk Jacquard, raw silk, rayon and pimatex cotton.


Try it out and have fun!
Posted under Dyeing